Well, it's hardly much of a stretch to say that there are different models of sizes of proton torpedoes, now is it? Photon torpedoes, far better range and speed. Who wins? The Protonic Arsenal space set is a three-piece space equipment set, comprised of a unique Universal Console, Experimental Proton Beam space weapon, and Torpedo Launcher, released with Season Eight: The Sphere. Page 1 of 6 1 2 3 Last . WikiProject Star Trek (Rated Redirect-class) This redirect is within the scope of WikiProject Star Trek, an attempt to build a comprehensive and detailed guide to all Star Trek-related topics on Wikipedia. This spreads the warhead’s energy out in a 360 degree radius from the center of the detonation. Also referred to as conventional torpedoes, spatial torpedoes are 22nd century weapons used by Enterprise. Unlike photonic torpedoes or any of the warhead's successors, spatial torpedoes are launched at sub-light velocity and can be used much in the manner of a missile, having the warhead on a fly-by-wire. In comparison, during that same period, Earth's Starfleet was still employing the spatial torpedo, although they soon upgraded to photonic torpedoes, the precursors to the photon torpedo. Then, a few episodes of Star Trek: Voyager ret-conned that with onscreen dialogue about various torpedoes. A team from the University of Leicester have examined the likely materials that would go into building Star Trek's photon torpedoes, and they find that it might just be possible to create the tech. A photon torpedo is a high-explosive device. Photon torpedos are bulkier, Protons are supposed to be pretty compact. Only quite recently did I figure out how to make proton bomb weapons functional in ES. JavaScript is disabled. The torpedoes can be fired from forward torpedo launchers in spreads of three torpedoes while aft torpedo launchers still use photon torpedoes. Post edited by nippeli222 on September 2014. Although there is no theoretical upper limit on the size of a matter/antimatter torpedo warhead - the Cardassian 'Dreadnought' type heavy penetrator carries a two thousand kilogram m/am warhead for example- warheads beyond the 25 isoton range tend to be too large and heavy for use as truly effective … CrtD: +20 Critical Severity 3… They became photon torpedoes, and then just photons. Essentially I wanted to be able to simulate photon torpedo firing and the fading colour changes that occur to the starship’s deflector dish. September 2014 edited September 2014 in Builds, Powers, and Game Mechanics. The 2 charges are each spent when you use Proton Torpedoes (see the Attack description of Proton Torpedoes). By mof9336, Senior Member on 7th August 2012, 11:33 AM Post Reply Email Thread. The 'photon torpedo' chain isn't made of plasma though, there are already other plasma weapons (the ones that are effective against armour). Your cursor must remain over the target the entire time. Better bang for your buck. This weapon comprises an elongated elliptical body some 210 cm long and 76 x 45 cm across. That's a bit of an unfair comparison. A photon torpedo was a projectile weapon commonly used by Federation starships throughout the 23rd and 24th centuries. This has been upgraded recently to increase yield by 5%. MWHHAahahaha... Proton torpedoes tend to be heavy anti fighter missles, while photon torpedoes are heavy anti capital ship missles. The weapon most widely used by Starfleet vessels is the Type 6. Once shields go down, the ship is usually screwed anyways. Yeah I use the prototype on my DSC toon and only difference with it and standard photon I can tell is the visuals, so your torp have this white/blue tadpole/teardrop shape when using high yield or normally and are white/blue balls with torp spread, the explosion is also white/blue in color but that's only visual and does no additional effects. Section 2 Technology 2.3 Weaponary. A phaser … Similarly, a photon torpedo detonated near a starship will always deliver some of it's energy to the target, whereas a proton torpedo will only damage targets inside it's cone of destruction. You can increase the yield by just increasing the antimatter/matter. The proton torpedo on the other hand, is probably fairly low-yield and low-range compared to a photon torpedo (this isn't surprising, they're supposed to be delivered by fighters and bombers), but if it can get close enough to the BoP, there shouldn't be a reason why it can't deal some damage. I decided to use the entirety of Red Squadron in this because Enterprise is a capital ship and I could not find any capital ships in Star Wars that fired proton torpedoes. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Say hello to zero point energy, bitches. Phasers. When it detonates, it does so in a spherical explosion. Torps are more likely to cause instakills, have 1,5 armor, 1,75 hull, 0,5 shield. Why are there Capital ships with proton torpedo launchers. KA shots twice as fast, is insta, overkill less likely. Bonus Round: The Enterprise and Red Squadron go head to head with everything they've got. Luke’s aim didn’t really need to be that good. What's the difference between the 2 weapons tho, even if 1 is matter and the other is energy (not plasma) and is misnamed, they both do … Well, it was believed in the time of the Original Series that antimatter detonations resulted in the total conversion of matter into gamma rays, which are highly energetic photons. Proton torpedoes tend to be heavy anti fighter missles, while photon torpedoes are heavy anti capital ship missles. Shields? The photon torpedo used shaped charges of antimatter that, when they came in contact with conventional matter or hard energy barriers, released massive amounts of gamma ray photons, hence the weapon's name. TORPEdO is set to be the first clinical trial performed in the UK involving protons. They used them extensively on board Raptor-class scout vessels, D5 class battle cruisers, and Birds-of-Prey. To fire a proton torpedo, position your cursor over the target and hold down the right mouse button until it establishes a lock. The zero-point initiator is powered by the detonation of an uprated photon torpedo warhead with a yield of 21.8 isotons. [Acc]x2, [CrtH]x3, [CrtD]x4 etc) 1. This really sounds like apples and oranges to me. The proton torpedo on the other hand, is probably fairly low-yield and low-range compared to a photon torpedo (this isn't surprising, they're supposed to be delivered by fighters and bombers), but if it can get close enough to the BoP, there shouldn't be a reason why it can't deal some damage. A proton/antiproton annihilation releases roughly 70% of its energy in the form of charged pions, while releasing the other 30% as energetic gamma rays. Value: Kelvin Timeline Photon Torpedo Launchers fire projectiles that deal heavy kinetic damage in a 90° arc. Maybe the photon torpedo can now be included on the list, and let’s hope that warp speed and world peace might soon be around the corner too. Proton torpedoes tend to be heavy anti fighter missles, while photon torpedoes are heavy anti capital ship missles. It also kind of invalidates a ton of vehicles, in a universe where proton torpedoes are a valid anti fighter weapon nobody would designate laser cannons as the mainstay armament for fighters/interceptors. So its maximum yield would be 3 kg converted to energy (1.5 of antimatter, and 1.5 of matter). You should be able to choose since in certain situations i'd rather spam missiles then hold down the key and wait for proton torpedo. 1998) This gives 95.73 (to 2 … Photon Torpedo Launchers fire projectiles that deal heavy kinetic damage in a 90° arc. 1998 G. Cox Assignment: Eternity v. 66 Greg Cox bibliography. Photon projectiles deal low damage but they have a fast recharge. Yeah I use the prototype on my DSC toon and only difference with it and standard photon I can tell is the visuals, so your torp have this white/blue tadpole/teardrop shape when using high yield or normally and are white/blue balls with torp spread, the explosion is also white/blue in color but that's only visual and does no additional effects. You don't have the time to sit there locked onto a target for 5 seconds to fire a torpedo, its much easier to fire missiles and when you have proton torpedoes equipped it wont let you fire regular missiles (at shielded targets) anymore UNTIL you have used all the torpedoes. Yeah, proton torpedoes are good but they should not be on the same key as missiles. A photon torpedo was a projectile weapon commonly used by Federation starships throughout the 23rd and 24th centuries. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. When a quantum torpedo detonates, the blast is focused entirely towards the enemy, allowing for far greater destructive potential from the same explosive yield Photon Torpedo Launchers deal low damage but they have a fast recharge . By the 24 th century the explosive yields of weapons are described in terms of isotons as compared with today's convention of using kilotons. The real question is which has the most power per unit volume of space taken up. It is more or less the same torpedo used by Archer and co, but the incremental improvements have made it vastly more powerful than the weapons they carried. Torpedoes would also increase in explosive yields, so its possible they managed to pack a lot more matter and anti-matter inside a torpedo for example, and have started switching over to quantum torpedoes due to having on average double the yield of photons... but in terms of energy delivery and precision, they might be much better than photons as well (plus, they might not use anti-matter at all - … So, say (hypothetically, that a photon torpedo puts out 100 "space units" of energy in the case of a hit. The photon torpedo can be set to fly a ballistic trajectory, be steered by the launch vessel, or can home in via its own guidance systems. For that reason it's also got a spot in my cargo bay ;p It really depends on your playstyle. Proton torpedos deliver a fraction of that, about 10 or so megatons based on some calculations, but are much more accurate and manueverable. It then goes on to say that the theoretical limits of traditional photon torpedo technology, 25 isotons, was reached and that the Quantum torpedo was developed to exceed those limitations. If you are looking for firepower, go with photon torpedoes. Talk:Photon torpedo. A second example of wasted energy is the charged pion production in a photon torpedo. The problem is that when I release the button it fires a normal missile instead of a proton torpedo, or at least I don't see any difference in when it detonates on target. Notes: I chose the targets based on the most well known opponent of each weapons system. Which one of them is better? (ENT: \"Fight or Flight\", \"Sleeping Dogs\", \"Judgment\", \"The Expanse… Comments If you liked this story, you'll love these Proton Torpedo VS. Focus Token Sign in to follow this . The proton torpedo on the other hand, is probably fairly low-yield and low-range compared to a photon torpedo (this isn't surprising, they're supposed to be delivered by fighters and bombers), but if it can get close enough to the BoP, there shouldn't be a reason why it can't deal some damage. If you are looking for firepower, go with photon torpedoes. A photon torpedo is a much larger and more powerful weapon, used for ship to ship combat, and delivering something like 65 megatons of explosive power. Shields drastically reduce the effects of kinetic damage. What's the difference between the 2 weapons tho, even if 1 is matter and the other is energy (not plasma) and is misnamed, they both do … Jump to navigation Jump to search. It also kind of invalidates a ton of vehicles, in a universe where proton torpedoes are a valid anti fighter weapon nobody would designate laser cannons as the mainstay armament for fighters/interceptors. You don't have the time to sit there locked onto a target for 5 seconds to fire a torpedo, its much easier to fire missiles and when you have proton torpedoes equipped it wont let you fire regular missiles (at shielded targets) anymore UNTIL you have used all the torpedoes. In 2370, B'Elanna Torres programmed the Cardassian ATR-4107 shields to adjust to all known weapons, including those used by Starfleet.When she last accessed the missile on stardate 47582, the USS Voyager, which was equipped with this type of torpedo, was not in service. Why are there Capital ships with proton torpedo launchers. I use High Yield Torpedo with Quantums I like 'em a lot. 1 View Entire Discussion (2 Comments) If we simply count photon torpedoes vs. fighters to be a smart move then all enemies have to act dumb to stop the game from turning into literal rocket tag. The torpedo masses 247.5 kilos when not loaded. The weapon most widely used by Starfleet vessels is the Type 6. Landis recognizes the challenges, though he points out that since you'd only need a tiny bit of antimatter to create an effective weapon, a photon torpedo could theoretically be smaller a nuke. Standard Modifiers:Can appear multiple times (e.g. nippeli222 Member Posts: 56 Arc User. 1 View Entire Discussion (2 Comments) Which weapons system would be more effective at taking on the following: Assume the Photon Torpedoes are fired from the Enterprise and the Proton Torpedoes are fired from the X-Wing's of Red Squadron (12 spacecraft total). A photon torpedo which detonates inside the hull of a starship delivers all of it's 64.4 megatons to the target, while a proton torpedo will merely blow a small hole through the ship. A number of torpedo designs were shielded to protect them from being shot down by either skilled pilots or the target's defensive flak guns. When a photon torpedo detonates, the blast occurs in every direction. They were used by the Royal Naboo Security Forces during the Invasion of Naboo, in which Anakin Skywalker destroyed the Trade Federation command ship with proton torpedoes. Photon torpedoes have warp capability (though not full warp drives) and so can go faster than light speed and engages ships also doing so. Or if given preference drones. A proton/antiproton annihilation releases roughly 70% of its energy in the form of charged pions, while releasing the other 30% as energetic gamma rays. If you are looking for firepower, go with photon torpedoes. A second example of wasted energy is the charged pion production in a photon torpedo. A charged pion will decay within nanoseconds into an electron and several neutrinos. The torpedo masses 247.5 kilos when not loaded. The m/am reaction occurs at four times the rate of a standard warhead; the detonation energy is channelled through the initiator within 10-7 seconds and energizes the emitter, which imparts a tension force upon the vacuum domain. Why are there Capital ships with proton torpedo launchers. Which one of them is better? Do they ever actually explain why they are called Photon Torpedoes? Proton Torpedoes. The first example that comes to mind is the. This makes them tactically superior to photon torpedoes in some ways, because there is no danger of damage to the vessel which fired the torpedo. Your cursor must remain over the target the entire time. Voyager firing photon torpedoes. Introduced in the late 2360s, the quantum torpedo was part of the range of projects which formed Starfleet's response to the threats represented by the Borg and renewed activity by the Romulans. Torpedo casings have been seen on several occasions as two meters long, black or grey in color, and demonstrate a distinct lack of glow. This weapon comprises an elongated elliptical body some 210 cm long and 76 x 45 cm across. Comments. They were developed in part due to the requirement for a weapon, … If you are looking for firepower, go with photon torpedoes. "If you need, say, a 100-kilogram superconducting magnet to create the fields needed to suspend a 1-gram sphere of antihydrogen, your photon torpedo's going to be a little bigger than a beach ball." Acc: +10% Accuracy 2. Description. Photon Torpedo Shielding . And somewhere along the way, it became unfashionable to call them photonic torpedoes. E6700,680i,8800GTx2 SLi,X-Fi,Vista 32-bit Ult,Antec 900. The warhead of the photon torpedo comprises a maximum of 1.5 kilos of antimatter and 1.5 kilos of matter. The way to think of this is that "per unit of time, the torpedo is more powerful" but that the phaser can exercise itself over longer periods of time. A brief analysis of and theory about the strange glow of photon torpedoes. Gravimetric Photon torpedo vs Enhanced Bio-Molecular Photon torpedo. They are not affected by Weapon Power. User Info: Algus. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the whowouldwin community. Depends on explosive power. proton torpedoes according to starts have some speed so they dont seem quite instahit weapons, so if that is the case, they can cause some overkill. Proton torpedoes were a type of explosive ordnance used throughout the galaxy. Comments. The 'photon torpedo' chain isn't made of plasma though, there are already other plasma weapons (the ones that are effective against armour). Uncommon Photon Torpedo Launcher has one modifier suffix, Rare will have two, Very Rare will have three, and Ultra Rare will have four. However, a large fraction of that energy would be released as harmless neutrinos. Photon torpedos are bulkier, Protons are supposed to be pretty compact. Once it's locked on, release the right mouse button to fire the proton torpedo. So a proton torpedo with a one gram payload does a heck of a lot of damage just by existing. Yes, that is how I understand it should work as well. Small starfighters like the Rebel Alliance X-win… Photon torpedoes. Depends on explosive power. Once it's locked on, release the right mouse button to fire the proton torpedo. Also photon torpedoes can be used as mines which phasers can not. Proton torpedoes tend to be heavy anti fighter missles, while photon torpedoes are heavy anti capital ship missles. Post edited by nippeli222 on September 2014. "If you need, say, a 100-kilogram superconducting magnet to create the fields needed to suspend a 1-gram sphere of antihydrogen, your photon torpedo's going to be a little bigger than a beach ball." According to the 2009 video game Star Trek D-A-C in the alternate reality, Starfleet had developed quantum torpedoes for use on starships as early as the 2250s. Gravimetric Photon torpedo vs Enhanced Bio-Molecular Photon torpedo. They are not affected by Weapon Power. One thing the two scientists agree on is who would win in a ship-to-ship battle between the Galactica and the Enterprise . Proton torpedoes came in a wide array of sizes and yields, from massively powerful capital ship weapons designed for orbital bombardment, to small but nimble fighter-grade weapons like those Luke Skywalker employed against the first Death Star. It’s complicated. Gotta wait till you get a lock on it. Come join our discussions, post your own battles and kick some ass! They were low-yield photon torpedoes. The real question is which has the most power per unit volume of space taken up. However, most proton torpedoes are low-yield devices intended for use against "soft targets" like ground installations or fighters, and proton torpedoes are generally useless against capital ships until their shields are dropped. Proton Torpedoes. Followers 0. Much of the concussive force is wasted by not actually hitting your target. However, they are functionally identical to photon torpedoes, albeit more powerful with the only visual difference being their color. 1996 W. Shatner Return ii. This makes them tactically superior to photon torpedoes in some ways, because there is no danger of damage to the vessel which fired the torpedo. This set is obtained from the Dyson Joint Command branch of the Reputation System. It aims to assess the benefit of proton beam therapy (PBT) in terms of patient-reported toxicities, quality-of-life and cost-effectiveness versus intensity-modulated radiotherapy (IMRT) which is the accepted standard of radiotherapy for the treatment of oropharyngeal cancer. Proton torps because two of them destroyed the death star, and you can arm fighters with them XD. According to the TNG technical manual, a photon torpedo can carry 1.5 kg of antimatter. Landis recognizes the challenges, though he points out that since you'd only need a tiny bit of antimatter to create an effective weapon, a photon torpedo could theoretically be smaller a nuke. nippeli222 Member Posts: 56 Arc User. They are kept record on by putting 2 charge markers on the Proton Torpedo card (see Setup and Charges in the Rules Reference). Generally, they can both do the job so long as you pack each with enough explosives. Upon impact with a target, the energy warhead would release clouds of high-velocity proton particles. 1 Console - Universal - Proton Particle Stabilizer 1.1 Game Description 1.2 Upgrades 2 … Spatial torpedoes are the ship's most powerful and primary ship-to-ship weapon before the installation of phase cannons. Photon torpedoes loaded and ready to go. 1999 M. J. Friedman My Brother's Keeper i. v… (90.55 to 2 D.P.) Photon torpedoes creating devastation across hundreds of kilometers (assuming no shields), indicates that a full spread of torpedoes (no number has been specified, and Klingon starships rarely have ever shown more than 2 torpedoes being fired in a single spread) from a relatively small klingon vessel can create an explosion in the hundreds of megatons. Photon torpedoes. "If you need, say, a 100-kilogram superconducting magnet to create the fields needed to suspend a 1-gram sphere of antihydrogen, your photon torpedo's going to be a little bigger than a beach ball." Polaron Torpedoes, like Quantum Torpedoes, are just differently colored photon torpedoes. That turns out to be about 60 megatons, equivalent to a very large nuclear bomb. We use cookies on our websites for a number of purposes, including analytics and performance, functionality and advertising. Epicadds a fifth unique modifier. 1. Klingons began using photon torpedoes by at least the mid-22nd century. What does AM/M weapons have to do with photons? You are indeed where you belong. Spatial torpedoes are themselves superseded by more powerful photonic torpedoes. For preference, quantum torpedoes. [ROOT] Photon-Torpedo Direct v1.1 (8/10/12) w/How To Video(New Video Added) 461 posts Thanks Meter: 307 . 0. Press J to jump to the feed. Shields drastically reduce the effects of kinetic damage. They were used by the Royal Naboo Security Forces during the Invasion of Naboo, in which Anakin Skywalker destroyed the Trade Federation command ship with proton torpedoes. "If you need, say, a 100-kilogram superconducting magnet to create the fields needed to suspend a 1-gram sphere of antihydrogen, your photon torpedo's going to be a little bigger than a beach ball." The Quantum Torpedoes were introduced as a new kind of torpedo to replace the old photon torpedoes. Ironically, the big effect of detonating the torpedo and releasing the protons is that the electric field actually drops. Landis recognizes the challenges, though he points out that since you'd only need a tiny bit of antimatter to create an effective weapon, a photon torpedo could theoretically be smaller a nuke. Proton Torpedo VS. Focus Token. Ah-ah-ah, now keep in mind that Star Trek doesn't have canon rankings. Now if 1 megaton = 2,977,789,639,020,840 joules; then 1 photon torpedo yields 90.5458953968987946834375526278729 megatons. Shields don't have matter to react with. The photon torpedo used shaped charges of antimatter that, when they came in contact with conventional matter or hard energy barriers, released massive amounts of gamma ray photons, hence the weapon's name. KA has 2x vs … A charged pion will decay within nanoseconds into an electron and several neutrinos. To fire a proton torpedo, position your cursor over the target and hold down the right mouse button until it establishes a lock. Your reticule will turn to THIS. However, most proton torpedoes are low-yield devices intended for use against "soft targets" like ground installations or fighters, and proton torpedoes are generally useless against capital ships until their shields are dropped. However, given that we know the quantity of antimatter and matter used, we should be able to make some assumptions about the comparative yields of the weapons of the Federation. Proton torpedoes were a type of explosive ordnance used throughout the galaxy. 0. Upon impact with a target, the energy warhead would release clouds of high-velocity proton particles. I created a copy of the proton torpedo launcher (which I had already created), increased the damage, increased the drag of the weapon, decreased its lifetime, and increased the sprite size. The type 6 photon torpedo was a type of photon torpedo used by Intrepid-class starships.. 14 William Shatner. 2.3.3 Explosive Yield of a Photon Torpedo. Description. https://forums.spacebattles.com/threads/spacebattles-merchandise.398032/. (Zimmerman et al. If you love to imagine the planet-exploding battles of the fictional gods who will never be, taking pointless knowledge gathered from a life spent reading and gaming and swinging it like a gladiator's sword in discussions on reddit... then welcome home, my friend. In regards to the Death Star, the photon torpedo is going to have to be a tighter shot; the torpedo is larger and has less maneuverability than a proton torpedo. September 2014 edited September 2014 in Builds, Powers, and Game Mechanics. I fiddled and faddled around for a while with discrete electronics, but decided to go with a microprocessor (ATMega328). The warhead of the photon torpedo comprises a maximum of 1.5 kilos of antimatter and 1.5 kilos of matter. Okay which is better to arm you ship with? If we simply count photon torpedoes vs. fighters to be a smart move then all enemies have to act dumb to stop the game from turning into literal rocket tag. Algus 10 years ago #4.